Yom Haatzmaut: Israeli Independence Day in Halacha Part 3

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

balanced in my approach here so i just want to begin by saying that what we're doing is we're trying to present what uh we consider the views of the main poi skim of the last century if anybody could uh bring in other information from other places can be very happy to see but uh we brought in the views basically of the tits eliezer yosef and so far we saw three arguments why perhaps would not be permitted to say hello on your mat the first one is based on the letter of the khasanesh and based on the opinion that's itself and rebel yosef that in today's day and age we're no longer authorized to make enactments make the zeros make takanos make additions to tsfila and so forth and this is something that now in our day and age it's beyond us we're not on that level to make a new decree to make a new enactment would be as if to say we are worthy to do such a thing but in reality we are unworthy to do such a thing to tamper with the jewish calendar where the jewish um ceremonies and so forth would be considered in a certain arrogance that we're worthy to tamper okay that was the first argument we get the second argument we gave was based on i just want to say that he does shiva is probably the authoritative chuva on the topic of hallow for a miracle and the hida says that one can only say halal for a miracle that happens for the entire jewish people not for a segment of the jewish people okay that was the opinion based on which many poison say that as great and as miraculous as 48 67 was it was not to the entirety of the jewish

Jump to a moment

1. 0:30balanced in my approach here so i just want to begin by saying that what we're…
2. 4:47just off the bat you're gonna knock him out no no no no just off the…
3. 9:54despite all of their setbacks and all their failures they're still waving the sword at us…
4. 14:38is only touching a very very small percentage of the secular israelis the vast majority of…
5. 19:25majority view when it comes to keyboard scalias in other words the opinion of the round…
6. 23:42are you telling me there were things items that happened in 48. okay we're going to…
7. 28:48these were yes a jew who doesn't learn torah will destroy any nation in the world…
8. 33:19according to the view of ramashifen do we consider it a miracle or do we say…
9. 38:15there's a third one ish right now we're all the sons of one father so even…
10. 42:28technical requirements a person could be very have great allegiance to the state of israel that…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.