Rabbi Dovid Hofstedter- Pirkei Avot Perek 3 Mishna 8

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Hofstedter’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

he's almost guilty it is a crime of mishai venaselan of a crime that he has puts himself in psychonautical fascists endangers his life be very careful guard yourself not to forget always remember what you have seen you might think even if it is something he forgets because his learning is too hard for him and he's too weary from his learning talmud endangers his life if it's sir milly but he removes it from his heart which would seem to imply that he which would seem to imply that he consciously makes an effort to remove it and to forget it he's mishaev an option now contrast this mishna to a mishna in perigdalid which seems to mirror this mishna but has some subtle differences be very very careful with your learning because of chicago inadvertently making a mistake an accidental mistake a shy gig by talmud is eulogy and it's as if he did it intentionally it's this if he did it amazing so a couple of questions arise number one why the repetition we learned in mission gimmel that the importance of not forgetting your learning and how how severe it is that is misenable how severe it is that is misenable and why does zatanna repeat again in mishnigimo also the importance of remembering your learning and not forgetting your learning secondly why the difference in the language in perigymo it says that he endangers his life and perigdal it is talmud talmud it's like forgetting even if he does it accidentally it's as if he does it intentionally it's considered like amazing so why the repetition and why the difference in the language and perhaps the shot is is that we're different dealing with two different aspects of the learning one is our parent paragumo is dealing with remembering and retaining his learning

Jump to a moment

1. 0:31he's almost guilty it is a crime of mishai venaselan of a crime that he has…
2. 1:32which would seem to imply that he consciously makes an effort to remove it and to…
3. 2:32how severe it is that is misenable and why does zatanna repeat again in mishnigimo also…
4. 3:33retaining his learning and if a person forgets his learning if he does it intentionally he's…
5. 4:36you should be careful having zoro battalion be careful if you make a shogi if you…
6. 5:38that is a hat of an omission of where he did not learn it he did…
7. 6:41hazra to review it that degree of negligence in not trying to remember the basic learning…
8. 7:42decorum they were able to retain their learning it had a great memory and sitting there…
9. 8:44but not because he was born with a great memory rav alconan he retains his learning…
10. 9:48that's how you remember your learning but i persisted and i asked but is there something…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.