Yeshiva Daf | Shavuos 27 | Rav Yechezkel Hartman

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

All right. Someone did a not to do. So he and he didn't do part. Why can't go gets the doz now is really interesting. He did a to do to still even though not against the is for the should have said something. You can choose to do it or not choose to do it. There's no still if he did he has obligation. So it makes sense if I if I'm I have I can do whatever I want. This works. So if I'm obligated to do a certain way of course should be should be something strong. It doesn't mean anything. Why? It doesn't mean anything. I could choose to say yes or no. I can do either or I can say I will do it or I will not do it. But the only option I have is to say yes to say I'll do it and I won't do it because it violates the that's for sure. You can't go against that's even according to the That's the learn to say you could go against but according to and the way we're abundant learn you cannot go against the so to say no I cannot go against the so to say no I can't do I want to say yes we have a rule you have to be able to do both ways yes and no here you can say yes no doesn't you have the option to do bad or good. So first start I want the want the is no why not so now right now we're not getting you can't go against but something else comparing bad to good the good is so bad we'll see them more why why why They want to explain one [Music] moment. So now I know that if you cancel

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00All right. Someone did a not to do. So he and he didn't do part. Why…
2. 2:42want the is no why not so now right now we're not getting you can't go…
3. 5:21Give you the body. But accord you gave you the body to be under your you're…
4. 7:57right? It's be exactly the same as the whole crisis until now. Can a person do…
5. 10:36too. Why not? Because if you because it's spiritually good even though it's pure good. He's…
6. 13:58shak that's why Right? In other words, if you're telling me that the Torah is talking…
7. 16:39once I say also already knew so why why is he going to say that again…
8. 19:26you need to have some something. So the fact I don't have anything you know it's…
9. 22:05the so he said all three I will not eat this bread I'll not eat it…
10. 24:39there if there's a way for if there's space it will come down it will happen.…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.