Yeshiva Daf | Chulin 38 | Rav Yechezkel Hartman

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yechezkel Hartman’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Good morning. We're starting today and we learn today starting in towards the battle says what did say? Remember this Mishna that we're dealing with right now speaks about him as a animal which is sick in about him as a animal which is sick in danger if you if it will die eventually it's not a said is only is a piece missing for the animal this is not it's not I'm saying it's just sick but uh it's not going to live and we learned in the Mishna that if as long as there's some sign of life to it then it's fine. So what say what is the sign if it's it's a Gore brings you a list of sim that show this animal's alive. So Goya Goya means made a noise. Each animal which noise it made uh the it basically put out and then moved her ear. So any one of these signs shows the animals alive says to scream. So making a noise um you know putting out feces and moving the ear. So I raise that's part of the pure which is the literal translations meaning of jerking that the animal does before it dies and it shows animals alive. In other words, does the sch is referring to Rav say something about that in a moment. But he says about that in a moment. But he says referring to Rav um needs to tell me the of moving the ear. Why Rashi says it's a lot to say to move the ear. You need to get to that. I say you don't have to make a big movement. Any movement that it's not a natural movement of death is is considered to be something which shows the animals alive. what we're trying to figure out as as we'll see in a moment

Jump to a moment

1. 0:04Good morning. We're starting today and we learn today starting in towards the battle says what…
2. 2:40figure out as as we'll see in a moment in the Gabbor the main point is…
3. 5:59splashing to far away. If it's splashing far away, that shows a sign of life, right?…
4. 8:37indication of life. So what stage they do it mean after did it. So you want…
5. 11:53that's what he's saying I don't know when it is says like is that's why we…
6. 14:28is good enough is mean you don't need to move both. Moving it's enough to have…
7. 17:35telling me that it's good enough indication if it's less and you need to do it…
8. 20:23baby this this baby cow as a carpet if I don't have to have life after…
9. 23:31says it's possible. Why? as we'll see in a moment. Even though he's checking in and…
10. 26:05what's what's the discussion they say I don't assume he's doing unless I know it says…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.