A discussion on free will and the 11th principle of Emuna.
Know someone who would love this shiur?
The sources this shiur stands on
Cited by Rabbi Lazer Brody in this shiur — tap a source to open it in the beis medrash, or the time to hear him bring it.
Ask this shiur
Ask in your own words — the answer is the exact moment this shiur speaks to it.
What’s said in this shiur
The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Lazer Brody’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.
Amuna my Lord. Amuna, it's from you my Lord. [Music] It's all good, my Lord. Oh Lord, with Hashem's loving grace, welcome to Amuna Hour number 211. Tonight with Hashem's help, we're learning the 11th Hashem's help, we're learning the 11th principle of amuna. This is the principle. It's called it's your choice. This is reward and punishment and free choice. Principle 11 as my manes teaches us. I believe with complete belief that the creator, blessed be his name, rewards those who observe his commandments and punishes those who transgress his commandments. Which means we have to take responsibility for actions. We can't blame anyone else. It's all up to us. And so what's up? Everything comes from Hashem. We learned the first principle of Muna. Uh yes, but the Gammor clarifies that everything the Gammor clarifies that everything comes from Hashem except for the reverence of Hashem. Fearing Hashem, honoring Hashem, this is up to us. So whether we're going to honor Hashem's Torah and the mitzvah or not. This is up to each one of us. We have to take responsibility because Hashem grants us the free will to do good or the otherwise. And with the Ramal explains there's no concept of a reward and punishment outside the context of free will, free choice. Therefore, there can't be the slightest coercion in any
Jump to a moment
- 0:00Amuna my Lord. Amuna, it's from you my Lord. [Music] It's all good, my Lord. Oh…
- 5:40commandment of Torah it is a rectification of the soul. On the other side every time…
- 11:48family. There's word of punishment. So we certainly uh we see this and up with the…
- 17:56it's an open book to Hashem. He wanted to he wanted to to to help a…
- 23:32these two chemicals together. Put nitric acid and glycerin together. Look out. Look out. You're going…
- 29:43because each one of us if we're here each one of us has the 50% side…
- 35:50the heart and the decision that was made up here by the divine soul is converted…
- 41:31big 2,000 lb bull, 2400 lb bull. And again, the divine soul of this little princess.…
- 47:40that dark side spirit comes, a person is a candidate for head of the mafia. And…
- 53:53puts a person in depression and good the influence of the divine soul it straightens the…
Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.
Why is this here?
Before this shiur could appear, it was reviewed against one written standard — the same standard for every video in the library, no exceptions and no algorithm deciding on its own. It was reviewed on August 15, 2026. It is listed under Torah. If you believe something here does not belong, tell us — every challenge is read by a person.
Get the week’s best, by email
One email a week — a handful of approved shiurim and music. No account needed.
Know a family who would use this? Give a Lehallel membership.