Daf Yomi: Succah 15

What’s said in this track

The opening of this track, in Rabbi Shmuel Silber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

okay so we had a mishna which told us there's Auda and and we had a m r what is the m and rav's opinion was that they were discussing using a four piece of wood Andor said that we made a right we said there's a daa there's a real problem if a person would want to sit in his house on sucus what's the source of that problem even if his roof would be made problem even if his roof would be made out of wood the source of that problem if the ter says go sit in the Suka that's the exclusion of his house so says mayor according to Rav that if I would allow a person to sit in a Suka made out of four te wood boards which was the the normal material used for their house roof so then I'm concerned that people are going to get confused and think you can sit in your house on circus and according to Rav Ruda said we circus and according to Rav Ruda said we didn't have to make such a decree in other words Ruda is saying I agree you can't sit in your house because that's a daa problem however I disagree and say that a person could yes use a for wood plank to build his Suka according to Shu everybody agreed we made a decree by four te boards the disagreement in the mishna was did we even make the decree on a board between the size of three and four mayor

Jump to a moment

1. 1:06okay so we had a mishna which told us there's Auda and and we had a…
2. 5:18board they responded that's not a that's not a good proof that's a proof that in…
3. 9:58started um with no good good no good good no good good so in the middle…
4. 14:35is paying attention to or a person put a wood a wood nesser which is wide…
5. 18:47and and you take out every other so right now if B means both it would…
6. 23:25that a person's going to get confused between that and his house so the gor says…
7. 27:58with b h according to Reb sorry re y said you can do either option you…
8. 32:04from using those materials because of a concern that he might get confused and use something…
9. 36:43wanted to turn his house into a su okay a normal roof was made out of…
10. 41:21roof Al together it's exactly 50/50 the that's okay which the is going to touch upon…

Every second of this track plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.