The Steipler on the Machlokes Ran & Rashba If Issur Hana'ah Automatically Makes Hefker

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words— taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay, good afternoon everyone. We have an amazing topic today on the Nedarim Daf page Amud Aleph. The Gemara said in order to reconcile this Tira on the Mishnah on page Gimel Amud Bet. Rava said really Tivas Hana Mamain. And that's why if you say I asked her these Kohanim, you can't give [clears throat] them Terumah Ma'aser. You have to give it to others. So why if you asked her all Kohanim Levi'im, could they take it against your will? Because once you asked her them, there's no one to give it to. Once there's no one to give it to, so there's no it has no value. So it's Hefker. Once it's Hefker, they could take it. The Lashon of the Gemara is Mishum De'Terumah Lo Chazya Ela Le'Kohanim. U'Keivan De'Ka Asri Le'Misra Alaihu, Shavya Afker Be'Alma. Since you're asking it to them, it becomes like dirt. The Ran then quotes the Rashba. This is the Ran on the second wide lines. We didn't read this inside because this is this is not an Igaya the Shat of the Gemara, but the the Ran brings from the Rashba an amazing idea. What would the Halacha be if you asked her fruits on yourself? Let's say you say, "These fruits are asked her to me." Okay. Well, wait a second. If they're asked her to you, then nobody should be able to come and take them. I'm sorry, if they're asked her to you, then they have no value. If they have no value, then people should come into your house be able to come into your house

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Okay, good afternoon everyone. We have an amazing topic today on the Nedarim Daf page Amud…
2. 1:34and take them from you. The Ran brings from this Gemara we learn that if you…
3. 3:12"Mihu heicha de it'shal?" If you're matter on your nether, "Chayav in leshalem." The person would…
4. 4:50The the other person's Kenyan my money wasn't off nullified. She ain't no might say she…
5. 6:23because you can't be hana'ah from them. Comes the the Steipler, we'll see in a moment,…
6. 7:56coming back to our Gemara, if you assur fruits to Kohanim, all the Kohanim in the…
7. 9:30Let's try this. Mhm. >> The stippler is found in Kilauea from Masada and Adam. Simon…
8. 11:08the net there you were not getting it. I should be allowed to keep it. It's…
9. 13:02children. Again, what the stippler is saying is that the mark like us the run and…
10. 14:36Have a great day, everyone. >> So but by the case of the Kohanim and Levi'im,…

About Rabbi Daniel Glatstein on Lehallel

10,675 approved videos from 2016 to 2026, 8,906 of them searchable by their own words. Open all of Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s shiurim →

Most played

Tefillah: Journey of a Lifetime - FULL SERIES {B'yomeinu}30:34 · 207K views · Sep 25YOU CAN MAKE IT HAPPEN.....B'yomeinu4:59 · 109K views · Jul 28The Coronation of King Charles III and the Coming of Mashiach {Torah Illuminated Series}4:28 · 65K views · May 8, 2023

More from Rabbi Daniel Glatstein

Avraham Created a Cow #Shorts0:47 · 112 views · Nov 5Raphael the Cow #Shorts0:58 · 21 views · Nov 5The Tunnels to Gan Eden #Shorts0:51 · 124 views · Nov 5The Rambam's Yom Tov #Shorts0:52 · 72 views · Nov 5Mystical Adventures in the Cave of the Patriarchs With Rabbeinu Avraham Azulai on His Yahrtzeit37:41 · 210 views · Nov 510 Sharp Divrei Torah on Parshas Chayei Sarah {Pninei Kedem}14:36 · 783 views · Nov 4

More on this topic, from other speakers

From Mount Meron to Mount Sinai - From Tragedy & Silence to Unity - Rabbi DuviRabbi Duvi Bensoussan · 51:25 · 900 views · May 5, 2021Before All Survival Templates, There was the Candle on Your Head | Likkutei Torah Reah Anochi #2Rabbi YY Jacobson · 1:38:29 · 1.6K views · Aug 7Rabbi Daniel coren shabb Shira tu bishvatRabbi Daniel Coren · 7:07 · Feb 10, 2017Orach Chaim 422:1 Forgetting Yaaleh V'Yavo on Rosh ChodeshTorah Today · 16:30 · 3 views · Aug 31