Getting it ready…
Rabbi Chaim Mintz discusses the question of Esau's free will before birth during a live Torah class.
Read the notes on this shiur: outline, sources, and more from Rabbi Chaim Mintz →
Know someone who would love this shiur?
Ask this shiur
Ask in your own words — the answer is the exact moment this shiur speaks to it.
What’s said in this shiur
The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Chaim Mintz’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.
I just started this because my granddaughter was telling me about you know their learning and guy in about the last week's parsha with a sovereign Yakov and I think you said that free will comes after birth you have free will after after a person is born yes so then how come when a sub ayako will rip the stomach a sub kick towards the building of the wrong thing and Yoko
Jump to a moment
- 0:00I just started this because my granddaughter was telling me about you know their learning and…
- 0:30building of the wrong thing and Yoko kick toys debates connected so that's explained that it…
- 1:00him to that not because a believer enough free choice it was automatic force pulling them…
Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.
More from Rabbi Chaim Mintz
Why Yaakov was not able to be comforted over the tragic loss of his sonRabbi Chaim Mintz · 31:40How does a Jew protect himself from those who want to destroy us?Rabbi Chaim Mintz · 38:58Jump for joy if you have a tzaddik living in your city!Rabbi Chaim Mintz · 29:47If you stagnate, you're Eisav; if you grow, you're YaakovRabbi Chaim Mintz · 32:00Avraham was ready to sacrifice his son, what are we ready to sacrifice?Rabbi Chaim Mintz · 33:13When is there a mitzvah NOT to listen to your parents?Rabbi Chaim Mintz · 31:19Noach was running the world from his boatRabbi Chaim Mintz · 31:01Message from Rav Chaim Mintz shlit"a regarding the Tragic Petirah of Aharon Nosson Lebovits Z"LRabbi Chaim Mintz · 4:07
Get the week’s best, by email
One email a week — a handful of shiurim and music. No account needed.
Know a family who would use this? Give a Lehallel membership.