Menachos Daf 109 - Nothing but the Daf with R' Eli Stefansky

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Mercaz Daf Yomi by R' Eli Stefansky’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[music] >> Good morning Rabbi We are holding by the mission on daf kuf ches amud beis. Hoymer Echod mikvasai hekdesh v'echod mishvarai hekdesh. Reboise, you think about it without the mishnah. You said you have a whole ranch, thousands of animals. You said one of these animals is is hekdesh. Which one? Which one? So we have a concept of v'chol mivchar nedavosecha v'chol mivchar nedavosecha l'Hashem It should be mivchar, to be the the the top. So hoymer echod, one mikvasai hekdesh v'echod mishvarai or he says one of my bulls vo yelishnayim and only have two hagodol shebahem hekdesh. Mivchar nedavosechem, you got to get the best. So now we take the same, we apply the same reasoning. You have three and he said the best, which one should it be? He didn't say the best. He said I want to give one of the bulls. It should be the best. What's the difference between two and three? Says the mishnah three? Says the mishnah shlosha, if he has three, beinoni shebahem hekdesh, the middle one. This doesn't fit into what we just said. >> [clears throat] >> So the gemara is going to explain. I'm just doing chazarah here. It means also the middle one. Of course the top one cuz the whole mivchar nedavosechem, you got to go to the top. Also the middle. >> [clears throat] >> So two of them are kodesh. So now I have a problem. Two, how do you get out of two? The gemara gives you an eitzah. beinoni shebahem hekdesh Pirash even yedama Pirashti I I remember designating

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01[music] >> Good morning Rabbi We are holding by the mission on daf kuf ches amud…
2. 3:04Either the kedusha was on the top one and not on the middle one at all,…
3. 6:10Reboise, I pay attention over here. It says v'chein. These two cases are identical. Shor shel…
4. 9:15loses out. Hamotzi mechaveiro alav haraya. Hashas d'as oh. d'yad baal hashtara d'achtina Hamotzi mechaveiro alav…
5. 13:01Sorry. Sorry. Skip the in Gila of the base of Haniah lay out there. And if…
6. 16:33base of the God. It's not a oil law. What? He wasn't mad this It's not…
7. 19:37of Jerusalem came off the masses of the camera came. If these coin army they they…
8. 22:39the mishkan and the ohel moed. It says two words mishol stumble oven an aveirah. My…
9. 25:44lav leilam shogeg we're talking about that he did it by mistake. V'he kamar. So he…
10. 28:47performed the avodah I believe 40 years in the base sheni. He was from the anshei…

Every second of this shiur plays inside FilteredTube — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.