SANHEDRIN 58 | Rav David Maman | Daf Hayomi

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rav David Maman’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Shalom n all nousen la fin duorter au début hier à la fin de l' appa said that when a non-Jew who transgresses a prohibition that exists among non-Jews forbidding relationships, he will be judged as a non- relationships, he will be judged as a non- Jew with the rules and sanctions of a non-Jew. If, on the other hand, he has a relationship with a Jew, but that relationship is only forbidden among Jews, then he will be judged by the Jews. It must be read in its entirety. Any and all prohibitions on relationships that are punishable by death for Jews will be at least a Jews will be at least a minimum prohibition for non- Jews. If there is no death penalty for Jews, it means it's not even forbidden for a non-Jew. So that's where the argument goes. It's not true. There are many cases where there is no death penalty for a Jew. So it's a for a Jew. So it's a forbidden relationship that is subject to fasting or simply a ritual washing, and which is still forbidden for Jews. Israel, Israel, it's the rest that interests us. When we are told here If a non-Jew has a forbidden relationship with a Jewish woman, then a Jewish woman will be judged like a Jew. However, if he has a relationship with a relationship with a non-Jewish woman, he will be judged like a non- Jew. The real difference between what we call " married according to Judaism" and " married according to the Gentiles" is this young woman who is married, having undergone Kidduin, who hasn't. This young woman is married according to the Torah for Jews, but she is not married according to the

Jump to a moment

1. 0:04Shalom n all nousen la fin duorter au début hier à la fin de l' appa…
2. 3:05seen that... The original, normally the real case is that this woman has a relationship with…
3. 6:44because when it's related to the sea, it's forbidden, and by intercourse, whereas if it's related…
4. 10:22allusion, we learn of the prohibitions of relationships. What does it mean for him to be…
5. 13:26explain that distancing oneself from one's father means distancing oneself from a woman who was married…
6. 17:07av Aviv, we saw Rabzer asks that the two cases, Viv and IMO, be similar, and…
7. 20:43Queoup, as here, I have a closeness with Sarah, like a sister's closeness. But Abas velom,…
8. 23:49bebito says that kouti, so kouti here is yet another expression for the Jewish name muta…
9. 27:41that would be permitted to them, permitted to Jews and forbidden to non-Jews, as if that…
10. 31:24asks for in the baskets for them, well, he would take them by force. So they…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.