17b2 Masechet Succah - Amud Yomi

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shlomo Yisraeli’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

good morning we continuing lines down from the top of the today's is being learned as a for the we all have full recovery amen this month's learning of the community has been dedicated graciously by the Shay family family families should be an ultimate for all of their amen so we are amidst a two language gas in the between the two major in B well there usually Surah Pita here would be Surah I think yesterday we mentioned the of how exactly the at unfolded when discussing what is allowed in the middle of a large Suka we had yesterday the discussion between Raba versus ran shmuel together combined raan shmu both saying that in the middle of the Su you have three a that is POS and in other words in order for a to become when you have nothing in the middle going across just air merely three of that as soon as it's three if you have if you have metal beams or other items that are not then four of that would be what you need to render the Su and Raba was the one that said no whether you're on the side which you have any the concept of or in the middle of the Suka for is nothing for is what you need in order to pule and render it invalid you need four amot and we went back and forth now we go going to see a second version of saying that the way the the the way they said it in nard which is really the city of of Shu and that was said as and now everything stays the same RAV is what changes stays the same RAV is what changes over here and we're going to go through the same back and forth again so

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00good morning we continuing lines down from the top of the today's is being learned as…
2. 2:49it's going to sound familiar we're going to um review it together we're going to go…
3. 6:11middle he's talking about from the side that's why it's still because it could be um…
4. 9:35problem we talking about adding up from the side to the measurement of four about six…
5. 12:45that in the middle it would be which is again in the second version and everyone…
6. 16:05eight of which is more than the minimum amount of required and therefore it's you could…
7. 18:59Su you only could fill in with that three of open air that you have you…
8. 22:09this wall for this Suka and that will give you two pule suas none of them…
9. 25:28this is is the first case is you have one long beam that comes and doesn't…
10. 28:52anything because there's no oil above the mat like like a hole in the roof now…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.