"Ichlu Mashmanim" - The Controversy of the Song For Shabbos Chanukah, New Insights, & 2 Niggunim

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

avram IBN Ezra not Evan Ezra Evan Ezra is a helic in Evan there's no person Evan Ezra that's just uh amaratus to call it that his name was son of Ezra and this song is attributed to him in past years we uh mentioned if anybody knows a niggan for it and last year I got an overwhelming response of various negunim so I'm going to share I'm going negunim so I'm going to share I'm going to share them with you at the end of this year uh most of them came from various family members of the belsky family that they were very kind and gracious to send me their personal recordings of the song either from descendants or relatives of Rabbi belski or his uh falma Ravi Wilhelm and the traditional Megan I believe goes traditional Megan I believe goes something like this is [Laughter] I'll play I'll play you uh the rest of it at the end of this year they have the traditional way of singing it and we'll learn it from that and there's also a beautiful above of a niggen but I want to just speak about uh the meaning of it because there have been many who have questioned the authenticity and authorship of this niggen in fact in Charlotte Bruno he brings a nice eye in that Rabino of he brings a nice eye in that Rabino of Rama koyan did not want to let the bahuram to sing the zamer because it's mashma as if it was enacted by atom but how could you say eat fatty foods Hanukkah for the needs of Shabbos Hanukkah we are on chanukkah the sudoys are rushes mitzvah so how can you say it's the

Jump to a moment

1. 0:32avram IBN Ezra not Evan Ezra Evan Ezra is a helic in Evan there's no person…
2. 2:12I'll play I'll play you uh the rest of it at the end of this year…
3. 3:49eating and imbibing alcohol on Shabbos Hanukkah and because of that there have been many who…
4. 5:27the streets are flooded some of them are impassable and this is a Fila Hashem save…
5. 7:33different birds Shabbos Hanukkah as we know that whatever you have you need to sell for…
6. 9:08that's they would sleep there meaning they could not go home but they had to sleep…
7. 10:41furthermore the conclusion of Rama is that since there are two opinions there for a few…
8. 14:37[Music] [Applause] [Music] before you remember yeah [Music]…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.