Gid Hanasheh & Tofu (Chullin 92b)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Real Clear Mishnah’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

welcome back to this next installment of real clear that video in which we like to take a closer look at something from the week's domi this week I want to discuss Wednesday's dive which presented a dispute between Ravan Lula about you know what exactly a part of this the sciatic nerve running down the leg is prohibited specifically Ravan who argued as well as Rob said that we can't say that the prohibition of Yuna not sure refers to prohibition of Yuna not sure refers to the primary stem of the sciatic nerve why because Rob says that part is hard it's completely inedible so can't be the time was prohibiting that must be that are actually prohibited it can knock knows the parts that are offshoots which are softer and are edible but Allah says no even though you're right ate so even though it's inedible still the tire did prohibit the actual your main stem of the sciatic nerve so the question is you the sciatic nerve so the question is you know how does it respond to Rob's point that it seems illogical that the term would prohibit something you know don't eat something which is in the food how does it make sense so in the economy find two approaches the first approach pre-madonna mo has a niche and others is that even though in the conventional sense we wouldn't assume at least that this thing could be called the food but

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00welcome back to this next installment of real clear that video in which we like to…
2. 0:31prohibition of Yuna not sure refers to the primary stem of the sciatic nerve why because…
3. 1:03the sciatic nerve so the question is you know how does it respond to Rob's point…
4. 1:33this thing could be called the food but the tariff said it is a food that…
5. 2:03Gong the rabbit Trevor gon says you're right it's not a food in no way could…
6. 3:07not related seemingly to the palate so perhaps perhaps you would violate even if they don't…
7. 3:37little ahead so I learned Sunday stuff and saw devolve bays and actually the the runner…
8. 4:07beauty says he's not tied Marcus for that abundance a he is liable and the Gemara…
9. 4:38second and ask ourselves why should there be any Russia isn't it are just stating the…
10. 5:10of a kilo the Torre uses remuda makes one rush no they're gonna make a different…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.