Rabbi Dr. David Gottlieb - Studies in Chumash: Laws of Reincarnation

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

what I'm going to tell you is all but one in the ramban's commentary in a couple places I added one little element of my own um you'll see you'll see I think it's pretty obviously right but I'm saying that so okay um look on page 1063 very bottom so okay um look on page 1063 very bottom of the page verse five when Brothers dwell together and one of them dies and he has no child the wife of the deceased shall not marry outside to a strange man her brother-in-law shall come to her and take her to himself as a wife and perform now between you and me I haven't perform now between you and me I haven't got a clue what a liate is the word in Hebrew is Yum and that's the word they're going to use perform yeu which is a type of marriage it shall be that the firstborn she can bear shall now the literal Hebrew is rise up on the name of his dead brother so that his name should not be blotted out from Israel then they just did all the details the other ways get out of it and everything else let me do one thing the everything else let me do one thing the picture here is Ruben and shim her brothers Ruben is married to Sora ruin has no children not from Sora nor from anybody else he's childless he dies shim should take s to wife to Pride to have a son and if they will have a son I'm just stating what we read in very simplistic terms then the name of that son should be ruen called

Jump to a moment

1. 0:18what I'm going to tell you is all but one in the ramban's commentary in a…
2. 4:24here would cause us some Wonder to exactly what's being referred to okay that's the first…
3. 8:34off but when it comes to naming the son they don't name him they name him…
4. 12:42family because he had no son give us a possession among our father's Brothers meaning their…
5. 17:20when it says arise on the name of the Dead Brother it means he's going to…
6. 21:29he's having relations with this woman he knew the seed wouldn't be his of course the…
7. 25:37been tricked into playing the role of e Judah she disguised herself and tricked him into…
8. 30:16and then when you come to um Aaron Onan so uh she becomes pregnant from Yehuda…
9. 34:23uh that's why if he if he has children there's no need for yum but if…
10. 38:28now I said I gave you all the evidence and then I said all of this…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.