Lehallel
Getting it ready…

Torah · 6:59

Sukkos: The Incredible Shaila of the Aruch Laner and the Lomdus of Rav Tzvi Pesach Frank

197 views · Oct 9, 2022

Rabbi Daniel Glatstein

Ask this shiur

Ask in your own words — the answer is the exact moment this shiur speaks to it.

What’s said in this shiur

Jump to a moment

  1. 0:30And so he did the maaseh l'kicha before the zman, and now it remained in his…
  2. 1:02taking it, but rather it being in your hand. And the proof is, cuz we know…
  3. 1:33to do a maaseh l'kicha? He never did an act of taking on a lulav and…
  4. 2:04implies the mitzvah is merely having it in your hands. However, the Or L'ner says that…
  5. 2:34their friend v'matana u'manasa chaser, they have to take it for a kinyan, put it down,…
  6. 3:35of Chevron, Rav Dovid Cohen, on the Mikra'ei Kodesh you have footnotes from Rav Dovid Cohen's…
  7. 4:05nachser, it is correct to be mehader to first pick it up b'hagba, have in mind…
  8. 4:36Yosef Chaim, he says it could be that the reasoning of Reb Chaim Berlin is because…
  9. 5:07that l'kicha say and the the hagba and the l'kicha bo'in k'achas, it's still somewhat problematic…
  10. 5:38But the kinyan did not happen until you actually lifted it up. So, what what's happening…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.

More from Rabbi Daniel Glatstein

Get the week’s best, by email

One email a week — a handful of shiurim and music. No account needed.

Know a family who would use this? Give a Lehallel membership.