Rabbi Raymond Haber - Shabbat Daf Chaf Gimmel (23)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Raymond Haber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

so we're discussing now with starting base is discussing the question of whether Hadlock does the lighting of the mirror make the Mitzvah or does the placing of the menorah make the mitzvah right so we say tashem Ashish the lantern Rashi says enter all right French and English right I see sheet the Lantern and remember you only have to Light One Candle foreign if you had a lantern that was lit the whole Shabbat is over is over if the Shabbat is over you put it out um and then you light it again so what's the proof what's the proof right if you say that it's good if you say that makes the mitzvah is it enough to put it out and put it back on I didn't make it yesterday right it's not on elbows it froze unable to stop it I don't know maybe yesterday right thank you it probably needs to be start just it probably needs to be start just started again so let's see what you exercise okay I'll hold it um it's not working let's yeah yeah that's recording for some reason we're live but the mic is not there's nothing here the micro light is not on but we're going to record anyway right this mic is working boys foreign then light it again oh so that's one proof that's a proof that the main Mitzvah is lighting the candle not placing the candles they're odd more than that let's listen to the biracial kids five parentheses since we said you see the Mitzvah leaks you see the Mitzvah leaks foreign right could you use a match or a candle or could you only lie directly from candle to candle when we rehashed the question we never we never got into that is it okay to use to use something else as you light it

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00so we're discussing now with starting base is discussing the question of whether Hadlock does the…
2. 6:01right could you use a match or a candle or could you only lie directly from…
3. 12:43you have to put enough oil in the candle before your light available let's say you…
4. 18:59for the week he's staying by someone's house well now he's not giving for the candles…
5. 24:06the duo vegetables does the best kneading and for smoking foreign besides we're putting in olive…
6. 30:32let's eat says where did Hashem told us don't Veer from what the rabbis tell you…
7. 35:52the truth is Rashi explains that not right she's sorry The Reef explains you know what's…
8. 41:34hashad now the question comes up nowadays nowadays A lot of people light inside so we…
9. 47:25should be good but sometimes they do come together if you put too many no floating…
10. 53:06the man that did the sin not the ladies so therefore that is all says the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.