Can Minors & Women Be Part of Hataras Nedarim? Reconciling the Rulings of Rebbi Akiva Eiger

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay, good morning everyone. Brooke my boy dafa shua daf I am has I'm worried stuff I am Zion. I'm worried I'll have. We're discussing the Sugiyama whether you could use pso lamb to be to do hot sauce in the dorm. Where it comes up most often is Arab Rosh Hashanah. On Arab Rosh Hashanah people uh they come to show and they know that one of the avoiders of Arab Rosh Hashanah is to be my turn a dorm. And you get together you gather together a three people together with you and they sit down and they serve as a best in. And you say look uh I can't there's no time to to annunciate all my Nader arm. I don't even remember them. And please I would like to annul them. I didn't realize I don't want to be in milk God by avoid in Nader arm before the Yom Kippur din. And the three guys sitting next to you whether they're tell me that I'm a flag him or they're I may have started a race up and they can't even read the English of the art scroll. They say motor lock motor lock and you're good to go. All those commitments you made you've conveniently disposed of them discarded them. The only thing is very often you know you're diving in the show and you have your kids sitting next to you. You have one kid who's 13 one kid is 15. And you take those two and you take another guy. Is that a valid best in three of the people are father and sons? Is that a valid court? So the more I says in the dorm that I am Zion so very of your sister may mar.

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Okay, good morning everyone. Brooke my boy dafa shua daf I am has I'm worried stuff…
2. 2:04Let me put up on the screen. This is a very important topic and will be…
3. 4:06Fine. How do we pass again regarding Korean could Korean be my turn a dorm the…
4. 6:40I'm a good din. You're a good din. We happen to be related. That's external from…
5. 8:45That with a Kiva girl says is if he wasn't checked. That such a cut down…
6. 11:17learning is you can rely on the rubber hot another is you cannot rely on the…
7. 13:21but don't tell the kid who's 13 okay go be my another with some other kids…
8. 15:23The dinner you have to be my favorite another is a dinner it's not a dinner…
9. 18:02So best in shock all now the best is not good anymore you can't have even…
10. 20:14can't you have a woman and and a child? The answer is not a court, but…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.