Daf Hashavua - Nedarim 83b

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay. Good evening everyone. We're continuing in pay gimmel lamed base. Pay gimmel lamed base. I want to want to share by Reb Yitzchak Yosef. And he asked, "What simanin Yoreh De'ah hilchos dagim?" And nobody knew. And he said, "Siman pay gimmel, rashei teivos gefilte fish." Yeah. Okay. So, but I don't think in this daf we encounter the gefilte fish. But we do encounter the shita of Reb Yochanan. Reb Yochanan holds that if somebody makes a neder, if the husband is made for the neder that is afflictive to her, the halacha is that he is only annulling the neder which is afflictive and he's not made for the one that's not afflictive. As opposed to Reb Yehuda name of Shmuel, who says that by annulling the one that's afflictive, he is perforce annulling the one that is not afflictive. Fine. So, the Gemara is challenging Reb Yochanan. Asei. Who's asking on him? I don't know. Who is the ba'al hamemra who's asking this question? Did we have any specific um makshan? I don't think we did. So, I don't think there's any way to know who the makshan is. Okay. Asei. What? >> That's called hazakah for basar. >> Meheichi teisi Reb Asi? >> 83 82. >> What? >> He's calling the page. >> You're saying Reb Asi? >> Yeah, it's an Asi. >> They said what is a Reb Asi? Huh? We didn't have Reb Asi Reb All we had was Reb Asi said in the name of Yochanan. And some say Reb Asi asked Reb Yochanan. And Reb Yochanan responded may fill him may fill him may fill him may Now, when the Gemara said Asi before, do they say it's Reb Asi?

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Okay. Good evening everyone. We're continuing in pay gimmel lamed base. Pay gimmel lamed base. I…
2. 2:43They do? Maybe beforehand it was Asi. Maybe we need to know what the word Asi…
3. 5:57One of the things, even though in the sifrei mussar and aliyah is interpreted, pay attention.…
4. 9:03asila hashem kol minion nazirus so she is chiyav to fulfill the whole count of the…
5. 11:47Benefit from people should be also to me like a Kohanim in a Yochol Ha'ofer. Said…
6. 15:01in general, she's not including her husband. And that's the reason why he can't be made…
7. 18:08Another reason. If [snorts] you're going to say that the husband is a person and the…
8. 20:49>> It means there will be situations where the husband might become poor. And in those…
9. 23:58so what happened to the question of why is it if she's merely offered to the…
10. 27:10cuz when she answers getting enough from people she doesn't mean the husband. I if she…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.