The Great Debate on Shape of the Menorah: Rav Herzog, Rav Kapach, Reb Chaim Kanievsky, the Rebbe

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi YY Jacobson’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

this story that we're going to share today takes us back 1,9 54 years that's a long time and yet we still remember it recall it discuss it and debate it we're going to go on a journey today discussing the great debate about today discussing the great debate about the Mana that stood in the B mikdash destroyed today on the 9th of of 1,954 years ago in the year 70 after the kamero in the Jewish calendar in the year 3,830 although some say it was 28 or 29 68 69 or 70 the story takes us on a journey from the holy land to Rome to Oxford Rome to Oxford to Egypt and to different parts of the world it takes us through generations from the time of the bikes to the days of the talic sages to the to the all the way to Great Scholars and Giants of our own generation and finally we'll bring it all together with God's grace and demonstrate a very powerful time Timeless and very relevant powerful time Timeless and very relevant lesson for our lives individually and collectively I want to especially thank the sh and everybody behind it for all of the Tish above amazing events including this one my friends Blazer and Heather Shiner Rabbi no shiner and the entire staff of the SCH for putting it together I want to thank SCH Gilbert for all of the video and PowerPoint

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01this story that we're going to share today takes us back 1,9 54 years that's a…
2. 6:08coins even in a cemetery they're found between five or 10 I believe and many of…
3. 12:22city is destroyed the temple is destroyed hundreds of thousands of Jews are murdered according to…
4. 18:35witnessed the First Crusade of 1096 about which we read today some of the kin some…
5. 24:50Jewish World Jewish history is the ram myties the rambam lived a generation after Rashi the…
6. 31:07the original handwriting of the rambam on top he's writing in Arabic he's describing what the…
7. 37:18took him over as the leader of the Egyptian Community after his father passed away his…
8. 43:36sheet here you have a closeup picture of this manuscript text he got I was MIA…
9. 49:52we're soon going to get back to Titus to the gate of tit Arch of Titus…
10. 56:12work now when we have the original handr written right handwritten depiction of the r of…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.