The Bar Mitzvah Series Part 11: The Lomdus of a Katan's Obligation in Mitzvos or Lack Thereof

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

until they're 13 years old so the you know i always say in life in order to enjoy something you have to learn about it the more you know about it the more the more geshmak it is the more enjoyable it is so so let's think about the concept that you're only five in mitzvos when one becomes thirteen what does that mean does that mean until one is thirteen they're not they don't have to do it there's no responsibility at all they don't have to do any misleads maybe their father has to train them but their father has to train them but they're completely potter and if they violate something they don't require any punishment at all or is it about other even mitzvahs it's just they don't get punished if they don't do it is it they have no kiev or is it they do have a it's just they have no aynash for example i'll give you an afcomina let's say a person remembers they're 50 years old and i remember when i was eight years old i was so fresh to my mother one time i was so chutzpa dick chutzpa dick do you need to do chuva for that or no i wasn't there's no does the child have to keep the torah it's just he doesn't get punished or he doesn't have to keep the torah for example a gentile a gentile doesn't have to keep the torah so does the child have to keep the torah when we say ben you'd give a limit's voice is it to the or only to the aynash

Jump to a moment

1. 0:32until they're 13 years old so the you know i always say in life in order…
2. 3:37which came later is not khal and the israel of zaros he was always a czar…
3. 6:44gemara says we have rahmonas and we don't punish the qatar but we're not miraculous question…
4. 10:26behemoth is one of the mr nayach when it comes to sham it is the guidelines…
5. 13:30but not because of him because of you the same way your bahama can't do at…
6. 16:52i'll give you an example you forget it shabbos and you turn on the light what…
7. 19:54so even according to this answer a cartoon is not really mitsuva in mitzvahs okay um…
8. 23:05you warning him are you warning him not to do it or are you warning him…
9. 26:21is it because there's nobody to warn me let's clara hakira is the cousin is is…
10. 29:33shouldn't do it learns the latter that it's different than a guy a guy there's no…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.