Who Takes Precedence To Make Hamotzi, A Kohen or Talmid Chochom? - Mishna Berura Daf Hashavuah

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay, good morning, friends. Shalom aleichem. Baruch haba'im. We're continuing in Mishna Berurah daf hashavua siman kuf samach zayin se'if yud gimmel. Eicha dilai kavu makom where the people sitting did not establish a place. That mean anashim kol echad mevarech le'atzmo that we say everyone makes the beracha themselves. Im kivein hamvarech lehotzi'am heimes kama lehotzi'es yatzei. If the one who made the beracha had kavana to be motzi them and they had kavana to be yoitzei, they're yoitzei. In other words, all of these requirements that they need to say, "Let's eat together. Let's sit together. Let's have a set spot." That's only to establish that without any further communication one [snorts] could be motzi the others because if they say, "We're gathered together to eat." and there's a certain kevius makom, that situation bespeaks that they're all in this together and one could say the beracha for everyone without even explicit kavana on anyone's part. However, if they're not kove'a makom, if Reuven says to Shimon, Levi, Yehuda, Yissachar, Zevulun, and everyone's straying around uh I'm sorry, if Reuven has in mind to be motzi them and they have in mind to be yoitzei, it works. Says Mishna Berurah se'if katan samach im kivein vuchulu peirush bidi'avad yoitzei. Bidi'avad if they're yoitzei. The shliach tzarich levarech kol echad ela lechatchila. The din that each one should make the beracha by themselves is only a din lechatchila. Meaning, in this case, let's say they're straying around, there's no kevius makom, they didn't say, "Come, let's eat together." Then if if uh Reuven says, "Let me be motzi you." and they say, "Yeah, I'll be yoitzei." it works. They shouldn't do it l'chatchila. They should not do it. They should only do it if

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Okay, good morning, friends. Shalom aleichem. Baruch haba'im. We're continuing in Mishna Berurah daf hashavua siman…
2. 1:30shliach tzarich levarech kol echad ela lechatchila. The din that each one should make the beracha…
3. 3:33necessarily make a Bracha Achrona. You know that. Standard coffee drinking does not warrant Bracha Achrona…
4. 5:36Im Hamisu B'Rabim If there are many people sitting around the table B'Yitzeya The greatest one…
5. 7:09than he. >> [snorts] >> Shulchan Aruch Harav explains, cuz it's his meal. He's the baal…
6. 9:12Says Mishnah Berurah, l'hakdimo d'tzavah kidusha, ve'omru chazal l'chol davar sheb'kidusha, l'f'toach rishon ul'varech rishon. For…
7. 11:19the frum ones. If you're doing it out of frum kite, it's it's wrong. It's wrong.…
8. 12:52>> Does that mean he's a guy? >> Yeah, there is a to be a guy.…
9. 14:57big other talmud chacham but not as big, then you should give it to the cohen.…
10. 17:04Um Im ma'am ba'al habayis o tzalma d'ba'al asuta d'chachamim, hu botzei'a. Afilu cohen v'talmid chacham,…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.