Daf Yomi Shiur in English Masechet sukkah Daf 19

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Hofstedter’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[Music] we're going to start from the middle of the armored approximately second word of a line after the two dots tonna and we've already mentioned this on daffy dalai donut base the gamora briefly mentioned this a few simple words in the braiser cell which we've known is the way is the term used for kosciuszko and let's assume there's long reads that are used on the long poles on the for cautious the reason it's called sal is because it's the term of soils as we've learned haitsa minasuka it protrudes from the sukkah nidon kosuke has the same as the sukkah and it's very cryptic we don't really know what this means the gemara is going to have a whole list of different explanations what talk is what this could mean asks what is this cell kosciuszko that protrudes from a sukkah that has the status of akasha sukkah on the first explanation is that let's assume a suk has typically got three walls it could even have four walls and behind the sucker which means beyond the wall of the sukkah is protruding some of the sticking out behind the sukkah that's called sal it's cautious it's protruding outside the sukkah says the gomorrah if it's just three wall if it's just sticking out over the back of the sukkah in on challenge do you not need to have three walls there do you not does a sucker not need to have three walls at least as we've learned at least you can't just have no walls where there is one wall there the back wall of the sukkah but you can't just have sticking out with no other walls and it will be kasha says the gemara badika the walls there are walls there which means that i have the sucker that

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00[Music] we're going to start from the middle of the armored approximately second word of a…
2. 3:10since the back wall was originally positioned to serve the inside of the main sucker not…
3. 6:57and it's protruding from the areas around it which are tsilos and the braces says it's…
4. 10:00seven of kosher vias you're even allowed to sleep under it however was there but when…
5. 13:56and one teh roof at the top says the kumar maita mayu de rabonon what would…
6. 17:18because they say you need a roof so to follow the majority opinion of the indeed…
7. 21:17then it will be kosher and even if i don't do it explicitly for samir for…
8. 24:29only because you did explicitly to sleep on her stoma but if you had no intentions…
9. 28:39and we deduce from there it's in brackets in the gomorrah however by tanner which the…
10. 32:07only if you have explicitly in mind it should be on a big mat that's the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.