The Bais Yaakov on the Deeper Truth About Sins

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shais Taub’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

yes all right thursday night challenge we're learning something different every week uh last week we learned some of sadik from musician hanukkah this week we're staying in that mode that sonic was a talmud of the ishbitsa so we're learning this week from the safer base yankee valatora was the son of the ishbitsa so a contemporary and a colleague a peer of rapsodic and he follows very much in the style of of his father of the ishbitsa of the mayor okay so here it is he said simmonkhof base okay fine um before we jump in here's a deep question how do you reconcile this is like every dmc they call it dmc meaningful conversation in every dorm room at three in the morning how do you reconcile between and how is the free choice and yet everything is orchestrated by hashem classic philosophical quandary okay so here's one approach from the base yankev uh here we go okay viato lei atem shalaktem ac hena speaking he's speaking to his brothers after he has revealed his identity and he says to them behold you did not send me here rather god sent me here you didn't do it what do you mean you didn't do it and they threw them in a pit they then they pulled them out and they sold them to into slavery and uh what do you mean you didn't do well you know you did it but really hashem was in charge the whole time that's what he's telling you he was telling them don't worry the amish there is in charge

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00yes all right thursday night challenge we're learning something different every week uh last week we…
2. 4:29thought process but he's telling him you guys you should know something whatever your thought process…
3. 9:06marcus mardus rabbinical lashes just to you know that people shouldn't think it's a cool thing…
4. 13:41a life 6 p.m it's like okay and it was 6 p.m with shabbos and then…
5. 17:48he's using though an example where one is really unsure what happens when one's attention okay…
6. 22:24can i make a more trivial fake trivia questions i wasn't really prepared to do this…
7. 26:58like a person who says um you know there's two parts of chuvas eva the person…
8. 31:11the objective effect of the sin maybe in the abuse there's big vast plan it was…
9. 35:49again you know i i just want to clarify again we're not we're not trying to…
10. 40:25were only from your own psychological perspective which isn't dismissing it and saying it's nothing like…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.