הדף היומי באנגלית מסכת עירובין דף עב

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Hofstedter’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[Music] we're going to start from the mishnah in the middle of the ahmed says the mishna khamisha and let's just recap we know that the rule is that if you have a person living in his own domain so to speak and he's sharing another area let's call it a hotzer and we'll soon let's call it a hotzer and we'll soon see even if they're sharing a very big mansion together and since they are also have their own private domains and also have a shared domain then that's considered from buyers to hotza and unless they make a ruvichat series one is not allowed to carry from the bias to what we'll call the hotzer hamish if you have five groups of people and every group is living in so to speak or the way the is living in so to speak or the way the mishna puts it but rakulin ekhod in a single mansion era they're all in one mansion but they're clearly not living all under the same roof or more accurately they are living under the same roof they're in the same mansion but they're not living in the same area so to speak each one has cordoned off has got its own mechitzas its own it's surrounded it's mechitzas its own it's surrounded it's got its own boundaries it's very distinct where each group is living but there happens to be the five groups are all sharing the same mansion and this mansion opens into a larger hotzer where that hot is shared also by the people in this mansion and also by other but him around the hotzer so here we have an issue is each of these individual so to speak smaller rooms within the mansion considered as separate butim and then they would not

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00[Music] we're going to start from the mishnah in the middle of the ahmed says the…
2. 2:37they're in their own little cubicle within this mansion they each have to independently join the…
3. 5:42that they said i'll say that you need that even though it has these mercits between…
4. 8:48that the machreicus is when the reach the ceiling the second opinion holds is only when…
5. 12:00according to the fourth opinion we saw before who says that the machlakis is when the…
6. 15:04whether it reaches the ceiling or doesn't reach the ceiling if it reaches the ceiling everybody…
7. 17:40if nachman says in the name of like this price of a buddha that if the…
8. 20:42considered separations and then they are considered as five totally separate groups and that applies also…
9. 23:44have five people who have joined the hut have made an aero within their hotzer and…
10. 26:47both hatseries can be considered a single entity you only need to have a one a-roof…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.