Chanukah - Inside Or Outside? The Great Debate in Jewish History -- Rabbi YY Jacobson

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi YY Jacobson’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[Music] the entire moon is sometimes reflected in a single cup of water one genim of the human body contains the code for the entire body sometimes in the smallest PR in the smallest detail and Nuance you have reflected the full picture there is one M kazal there's one statement in medish that describes the tragedy and then the Triumph of and commentators over the generations have struggled to understand the expression that are the rabbis used when they wanted to describe what was going on during the time of Kaneka it's found a few places in medish the first time is right in the beginning Med on the when it says Earth was engulfed in chaos and darkness over the abyss and kazal the sages see that verse as referring to the various Empires that will dominate the world till Messiah comes and often plunge the world into darkness refers to Mal the Greek Empire why your First Source says the Greece which was sharp and Swift with its decrees upon the Jewish people the Greek Empire the Greek leaders would tell the Jewish people write on the Horn of the ox that you have no Shear in the god of Israel is right on the Horn of the ax why on the Horn of the ax it's not the most comfortable place to write a message I can understand write it on papirus on the paper they had then the clay or other material used to inscribe to engrave to write write it on the Horn of the ax I once saw ma a commentator say that the Horn of an ox was us was often used like we use today a baby bottle to feed babies meaning meaning this is what you should feed your children it's still strange that the rabis chose this

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00[Music] the entire moon is sometimes reflected in a single cup of water…
2. 6:14of if you place candles above 20 approximately 30 or 40 feet so then you do…
3. 12:27case smile why the mza is on the right so this should be on the left…
4. 18:35instead he He suggests let's throw him into a pit let's throw him in not throw…
5. 24:51take one face we take one interpretation and that's usually enough to challenge us stimulate us…
6. 30:58what is to what is the question the their vocation is RO their Shepherds the T…
7. 37:27mosha told the Jewish people from Hari from Hashem that every Jew is that the Jewish…
8. 43:41the ultimate danger there will not remain a Sid and a poit of Bas isn't that…
9. 50:11says me warm up for you a cup of tea so he takes the Chic the…
10. 56:45right and him wrong it won't prove him wrong we killed him when he was 17…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.