5a3 Masechet Makkot - Amud Yomi

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shlomo Yisraeli’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[Music] and for of Amen so we have basically still in the middle of the Su that we started with different different groups of witnesses that come to the B contradicting each other so says the if we have a group that comes and says we witnessed that on Sunday Reuben killed someone okay the second group comes and says well you could not have seen this on Sunday because on Sunday you were with us on Sunday you were with us now they themselves say well we're not disagreeing that Reuben killed Shimon we actually are testimony to the fact that Reuben killed sh we saw it we saw that Reuben killed sh you could not have seen it because you Sunday were with us in a different place we saw Reuben kimon on Monday so they're not disagreeing the two groups of edim it's not that they are colliding in their actual Ed that are colliding in their actual Ed that Reuben killed Shimon but rather they are just disagreeing when it happened and the second group says that the first group could not have seen the murder because they were in a different place with them so it says even if their Tes chronologically preceded the testimony um the alleged per testimony of the um the alleged per testimony of the first group in other words the first group says we saw this happen on Sunday second group says no Sunday you were with us it actually happened on Friday it happened on Friday so what's the difference by the way the difference is that at the time that they claim it had happened the first one already the guy was dead right so you're not TR trying to get somebody killed because he already had killed so says both of those scenarios you know what we do with the

Jump to a moment

1. 0:03[Music] and for of Amen so we have basically still in the middle of the Su…
2. 2:38scenarios you know what we do with the first group of adim we kill them even…
3. 5:47us right you hear what's happening so they could not have seen Reuben killing Shimon because…
4. 8:57say um the first group of come and say Reuben killed Shimon on um Sunday killed…
5. 12:09edim the first group of witnesses said what they said Reuben was he was already ping…
6. 15:36but it was a Friday that means it wasn't what you saying on Sunday but it…
7. 18:08previous Sunday 4 days ago he stole right the second group who proved them wrong they…
8. 21:13anybody claims that it happened twice right they say it happened once it's just that when…
9. 24:20be killing so why are you killing anybody even so says the no a very answer…
10. 27:24as we couldn't disprove the third group group said we don't believe them even though that…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.