Chanukah: The Lomdus of the Shamash - Ramifications of the Machlokes Rambam and Rashi

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Daniel Glatstein’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

let's begin as follows [Music] window but what about when it's dangerous interesting by the way rashi says what's shasta the persians had a law that on their holiday they would not allow people to light candles only indoors okay uh that's what happened so a time of the second one was dangerous to light outside you put on your table and fair tech is good enough omar you need another candle to use the light in other words known as the shamish the eco medura and if there's a bonfire loitzarach then you don't need another candle because you have the bonfire via them if you're an adam khashoggi doesn't use a bonfire affidavit this is the gemara of shamish you need another ner to use the light but if you have a madura you have a fire in the house you don't need a naraharas fine so far so good come oh yeah what's going on yeah so i'm sorry could i get a mission broke like above mishna so i believe the mahabharat says and simon tough aleph says like this foreign fine that's tough safe comes in tough ayan gimmel sif alef says to the added light so the obvious question is says that you have to light a shamash as the gemara says you're required to and suffrage says you know the most important lack of education in this generation is people have no shaikhs what's a minor and what you have to do and what's the drab on and what's their isa islamish the minogue becomes kodesh kardashian oh his

Jump to a moment

1. 0:31let's begin as follows [Music] window but what about when it's dangerous interesting by the way…
2. 4:39it doesn't make it a minute but no shy customers your father does minogue is what…
3. 8:54light outside that's the khakira the flow of hagamar is mashma that perhaps you could say…
4. 13:39[Music] even even if you don't need it why we'll see even even inside…
5. 18:15kevski quotes from and he says look in the avi ezri abhyazri says if your third…
6. 22:41so it's there in case you're misdamaged it could be right there now shane came to…
7. 26:28we have eight candidates so one thing it might depend on how many candles uh no…
8. 30:48wow yeah in that case we need them to read or something in case there's no…
9. 35:04right i understand what they're saying but the narrow hanukkah once there's enough oil to last…
10. 39:28that the other candles are for pursuing issa then the it's not a hefsik it's like…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.