Masechet Bechorot Daf Yomi Daf 19

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi David Elmaleh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

19. We're starting from the Mishna. We're talking about right now or any child which comes after. Remember means that it came out of the the the it's a C-section. So it came out of the side. It's like coming out of the wall. Dolphin literally is like a wall. So it came out of the wall. It didn't actually come out naturally. So he come and he says and the child which comes out afterwards which is natural both of them have to graze until they get a blemish and then they're going to be eaten when they have a blemish to the owners and they're not right is by the way you should know the same apply to a regular child correct the same thing C-section there's no right he says the first one is not a but it's not means it opens up the uterus here the word didn't open up the uterus. It came out through the wall. Yeah. The second one >> would say that from the the is down it open this. >> Yes. >> Through the wall it's something and from the uterus is like that giving the birth this way could be the first time through. >> No but but when it says through the uterus there's a uterus opening. The cervix is the entrance of the uterus. So therefore, and and the vaginal canal is the is the entrance of that entire area. So therefore, if you're going to do it through the stomach, that's that's through the wall. That's not through the that doesn't open up the opening. You understand? That's ku that you know, instead of coming and using the door, you're going to breach the wall. You're going to say it doesn't matter whether you breached over here, here, here, or there.

Jump to a moment

1. 0:0419. We're starting from the Mishna. We're talking about right now or any child which comes…
2. 1:41>> You understand? You know, at the end of the day, it didn't open up anything.…
3. 3:15about males, right? So if it's going to be a male I would have thought to…
4. 4:47there's like a whole thing that even means even if she went once and she had…
5. 6:36not a he learns from where from the he says so we have like a contradiction…
6. 8:14is considered a so why does it say then he's not a he's a second or…
7. 9:53that's why we we needed to say like that the word means 100%. And therefore it's…
8. 11:33birth at all. So therefore if they give birth within the thing for sure it's going…
9. 13:13But as if he didn't, it goes to the kohhen. Now if you have a it's…
10. 14:50not have a right? Why is it that we do not have a So he says…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.