A Fascinating Conversation with Jewish Historian Yehuda Geberer on the War in Israel, Graphic New...

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in The Motivation Congregation’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

welcome in we have for ourselves a big treat somebody who I look up to in the world ofma and in the world of arbas saaya and definitely in the world of podcasting it is with Macha katov that we welcome into the podcast the great historian the expert historian Yehuda gber can you hear me sir thank you yes thank you so much a warm introduction it's a high bar to live up to so I don't know if I'm an expert or a historian but I I will you know do my best and thank you so much for having me it's a pleasure to be here I want to put forth right away that the reason that we're having this interview is because we're in an unprecedented time this is a time where CLA definitely feels like there is AAS hadin it's a time of war and it's a time where we're not really sure how to react really whether we should be reacting in ways of action what to be thinking so I immediately thought of well doesn't seem like anything new because aash there's nothing new underneath the Sun so why not go get a historian who knows about what happens in wars and knows how this stuff kind of goes down and what we should be thinking and luckily Mr UD gber agreed to come on the show I'd like to begin the interview with just jumping at it and I'd love to hear exactly what you thought when you heard of the brutal attacks that were perpetrated believe it was October 7th by this war in Hamas between Hamas and Israel what were your initial thoughts when you heard about what was going on and what happened so um the initial thoughts or rather what my stages of hearing took place incrementally because

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00welcome in we have for ourselves a big treat somebody who I look up to in…
2. 5:51where you know the Bam are stealing the toras and probably drinking a bit too much…
3. 11:49need to confront it it's a form of denial um that that we you know we…
4. 17:41fillan maybe and maybe even gave his life for it who knows but the point is…
5. 23:59these are gar now they did not have video and pictures in the time of Kaz…
6. 29:45little bit of History so so thees says that um it says by he says it's…
7. 36:00the book of the secrets of the the soul I believe it is Hoffman one the…
8. 42:31to declare as one of the top five most yeshivish Gentiles uh amongst uh Carnegie and…
9. 48:27what should we do what should we be doing in this situation exactly what you asked…
10. 54:31that can't be denied and I can't be flagged for that like you you said about…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.