Logical Translation in Vayeitzei - Rabbi Dr. David Gottlieb

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Hidabroot - Torah & Judaism’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

I we started this yesterday this is Jacob's dream where he sees a ladder set between heaven and earth and he sees what we could call angels strictly in the Hebrew its agents of god ascending descending on it and God gives him a long promise that God is going to take care of we're up to the second half of verse 12 behold angels we could say or agents of God were ascending and descending on the ladder now our goal in this hour is literal logical investigation we're not doing symbolism or psychoanalysis or ancient belief systems or economics we're talking about what the words say and what on the basis of a logical analysis they could possibly mean and here there is an obvious difficulty if you're thinking of angels the normal thought is that the home base of the angels is in heaven they're gonna be sent on missions the round trip ought to be descending and ascending but the text puts ascending first so something's out of the ordinary something isn't doesn't fit the normal picture of the subject now I want to just introduce a category when you're interpreting a text there are two levels in which you could interpret one is you're trying to figure out what the text means you analyze it and you can deduce that it must mean this let us say at least this might mean

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00I we started this yesterday this is Jacob's dream where he sees a ladder set between…
2. 3:52have been the opposite it should have been descending and ascending leaving their home base and…
3. 7:39ones that have in a company over the last 20 years and the old ones which…
4. 11:21could the text possibly want to communicate by speaking of Abraham as a sob and Isaac…
5. 15:09descendants of you vaght that's not the point of the text the one of the text…
6. 19:01role model all three passages fit directly into what was going on Jacob life at the…
7. 22:51American desert in the southwestern United States is called the Dust Bowl that's because almost nothing…
8. 26:38will give me I shall repeatedly tithe to you now when it's back at 15 and…
9. 30:22to have earned that's why on 147 he says if because a promise to the Prophet…
10. 34:12of life when a person says I didn't know when is it common and important and…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.