23a-23b Gemara Avodah Zarah - Amud Yomi

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shlomo Yisraeli’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

by the family for family abah far Victoria and for Shir for um we're on we're on right 23A where we uh said I should go back a little bit to RAB Pat just as a quick review it's uh a right around the middle RAB Pat is answering the question right he was bothered by are we allowed to buy an animal from a or are we not allowed to buy an animal from a seems to be a s oneish says yes says no which one is it what's the answer so Rabat says no problem it's not M I mean it's not it's not a s it's not a contradiction there's a some people say yes some people say no says you cannot and the say you may buy uh sorry did I get that flipped around right says you cannot and say you could you could buy an animal from an uh from a that is the answer to the question according to rat right now how does he bring a proof he brings a proof that there's a by the red calf that we you know we we know that a red calf has to be says you cannot buy it from a say you could buy it from a so you see take that apply it to every other about buying an animal from a and it comes out that there's a between and about whether or not you can buy an an animal for a go from from a to use as a a uh to use as a Corban which makes sense now the thear says maybe that's not true right maybe that's not

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00by the family for family abah far Victoria and for Shir for um we're on we're…
2. 3:08with the red calf if he uh knows that he's going to lose out on such…
3. 6:58said so that that's the disproving this point which is to say sure makes he's he's…
4. 10:38that agree with and then you only have one in the if you do that you…
5. 14:24disagree with him because otherwise they wouldn't have brought a proof against rezer if they hold…
6. 18:09describe that is is it is it umad to the actual right the or is it…
7. 21:23actual animal's physical body is not kados at all it's just it's just a regular animal…
8. 25:12uh a big path that I think we're going to we're going to we're going to…
9. 28:59if has the laws ofat for so then it should have the law ofat that a…
10. 32:46agree that doesn't apply to so the idea that Rim holds that a uh Corban I'm…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.