Mixed Up About Mixtures? (Chullin 100a)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Real Clear Mishnah’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

welcome back to real clear dot video in which we'd like to take a closer look that's something from the weak stuff Yomi this week I'd like to take a look at the bar we learned on Thursdays def that's cool I'm at Olive the Mart there discusses the following case once upon a time a person had a pot of meat and the gravy - and also liquid in the pot everything kosher then a piece of everything kosher then a piece of novella non kosher piece of meat fell into the pot so you know classic kind of situation so Robin barbara hunted there rules that if we have the volume of the permitted substances you know meats liquid and gravy everything there all of that equals 60 times the volume of the prohibited piece of meats and it's not a problem the whole mixture is permitted problem the whole mixture is permitted Rob they're strongly objects - Rob Bironas really even though seemingly sounds a very neutral very power of no pun intended but Roth comes along and says you know I have an issue with this and it's a little more you know subtle here because it's not really with something that Robbie rohana I know stated explicitly it's what he implies for the categorical nature of he just for the categorical nature of he just categorically says that if we have 60 times it permitted stuff then it's fine it implies that that would hold true even if there was like a progression here even if initially in the pot we only had let's say two pieces in one culture piece and one navale apiece robbery harm plot is that even if we only added the other stuff later and we

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00welcome back to real clear dot video in which we'd like to take a closer look…
2. 1:02problem the whole mixture is permitted Rob they're strongly objects - Rob Bironas really even though…
3. 2:32the veil of flavor at the piece B it's not just that piece B has you…
4. 4:07Rav says I don't agree with this ruling at all he says this is not the…
5. 5:39explaining though now we understand now we understand that therefore I've needed to first tell us…
6. 7:11we're going like Reb you who da so we have the same type here it's me…
7. 8:13for me to understand what this round is saying how do we understand this let's go…
8. 9:48normally we go by rove and that should be it you know we we don't know…
9. 11:22Bodom that the term refers to the Dom of the site or the goat sacrificial blood…
10. 12:55not a straightforward you know you have a prohibited item you're mixed in you're right that…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.