Ticha Béav : pleurer sur un temple si vieux ? (Rav Shimon GOBERT)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Torah Box’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

You know that to participate in a particular event, you have to have an entry ticket. If you don't have the entry ticket, you can't participate in the event. Soon, we're going to have the most extraordinary event in the world, which will simply be the arrival of the Messiah. And to participate in this event, we need a ticket. We need an entry ticket. I ask the question: what is the ticket, and how do we what is the ticket, and how do we obtain this ticket to be among those who will see Jerusalem rebuilt? So, we answer with one sentence: " Whoever believes in the destruction of Jerusalem will merit to see Jerusalem rebuilt." I won't hide from you that when rebuilt." I won't hide from you that when I first heard this, it was extremely difficult for me. Why? Because we are being asked to believe in something we have never known, never experienced, never understood what it was. And even though now, God willing, we hear a lot about it, we are told about it in Midrashim and by scholars, we haven't lived it, we have Not having lived through it is like what we're told about the choice, meaning that we know it was terrible, we know it was that we know it was terrible, we know it was horrible what happened, but there's a world of difference between having lived through it and having heard about it. Here, a priori, I'm being asked to mourn the destruction of the Bethamigdash when we didn't know what the Bethamigdash was. We didn't live through it, in any case, excuse me, we didn't experience what the Bethamigdash was, and not only that, it's been 2000 years, 2000 years. So how can we mourn a Bethamigdash that Bashem, once again, knows

Jump to a moment

1. 0:08You know that to participate in a particular event, you have to have an entry ticket.…
2. 2:40alongside them, there were children who never stopped crying. In fact, Remstein explains that the difference…
3. 5:41babies. So then I thought to myself, there's a problem. If now I tell myself that…
4. 8:50moment you turn to the idol, well, you will end up making it a god. Here…
5. 11:57and I throw myself into the altar you expect of me. I give my life for…
6. 15:12a shower. I, C.I.S., it's a law, you asked one thing for seconds. Stop washing yourself,…
7. 18:16suffering? It bothers you, you ca n't take a shower, you can't take a shower, but…
8. 21:23the only thing left of their house is a piece of the garden wall. I ask…
9. 24:27pumped, but how is it, aade Bou, he doesn't have a house, you know that when…
10. 27:37see Rabbi. He said maybe their masal (birth order) wasn't good, and that maybe they should…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.