Chulin Daf 46

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Moshe Meir Weiss’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay. We gathered to learn another wonderful doctor Mara. Um We are holding Um By I hate from the shadow. Which is six lines from the bottom of that man have a base. Six lines from the bottom of that man have a base. Mark, I'm sorry you called me and I I never returned your call. Is everything all right? >> Yes, Rabbi. Just a quick question on the partial share. That's all. >> Oh, okay. We'll talk. Um It's good to see Dr. Yudel back and joining us. Uh Six lines from the bottom of my head my head of a base I hate from the shadow. So the spinal cord which starts by the brain. Where does it go up to that we say that if it's severed it's a treif? So says the Gamara, now you have to know the spinal cord is a complicated mechanism. Uh when it gets it goes all the way down to the tail. But when it gets to a certain point it starts branching off. And it branches off at least three times. In other words, it continues down. The central cord continues down to the tail, but it branches off and goes down to the sides of the animal. If you have an article, you'll see the picture. Uh could show you a picture here. See the branches? Branches off. Uh So so till till till till how far is it considered the the the spinal cord that if it's severed, it's a treifa? >> It's a lot more than the branches. >> And then we'll see what the din is with

Jump to a moment

1. 0:04Okay. We gathered to learn another wonderful doctor Mara. Um We are holding Um By I…
2. 3:09two sets of branches. Now the Gemara is going to ask, is it between the first…
3. 6:49it's not going to be a treifa because it's only up till the beina prashos and…
4. 9:58It's only vital until between the wings. Amar Ulla, "Rebbi Kim nikamei d'bein Pazi." I was…
5. 13:41know. They did They did whatever they wanted. So, Or Chuvrava and Rav Yosef, so Rav…
6. 17:23know what the shabbos. Either mine do you remember came over that has to be next…
7. 20:33He doesn't understand that I have to keep the natives engaged. Uh But really really uh…
8. 24:14so that means the hole goes through and through, it's a treifa. V'lo, but if it…
9. 27:23Uh okay, so we welcome in Herschel Wolner, >> [clears throat] >> Reuben Chanukah, Reb Velvel…
10. 31:08a carbon. He wants to shecht it. The din is you could shecht it if he…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.