Jewish Sources - Rabbi Dr. David Gottlieb

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Orlofsky’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

I we usually talk about two parts of the tradition the written in the oral I want to describe to you a third part which is not written in that world the written not written in that world the written and the oral have in common that they are both in words sentences paragraphs chapters books they both in language it can be written and spoken the third part is not in language it's not in words probably can't be put into words in any practical way I used to say that it couldn't be put into words theoretically then a student pointed out that my proof then a student pointed out that my proof was not correct so I've taken that back but certainly in no practical way it's far as we are concerned terms are dealing with it living with it interacting with it it's beyond language all together now what I want to do is first of all show you some traditional sources which indicate that there is such a thing then second what the status of such thing is if it's not in words of such thing is if it's not in words what is it could it be right or wrong to or false factual this is just emotion and then third I want to talk about where exactly it's found Jewish Lee and how we can deal with it interact with it so first step is to resources that show that there is such a thing there's a person d'ivoire involved chapter 6 of Deuteronomy you take this verse 14 where

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00I we usually talk about two parts of the tradition the written in the oral I…
2. 4:06wrote down a number of rules those rules are precise and focused scribed stealing murder applying…
3. 8:16didn't blow it correctly you're a show for isn't valid and you might run to find…
4. 12:25problem that on a sonar scope certain schools of fish looked like enemy submarines and that's…
5. 17:02feel right what do you do you say but there are rules the tradition has rules…
6. 21:08Moses than anybody else because part of whom Moses is shows in what he does and…
7. 25:17pause here emphasize that word and say these true music you're playing music where are the…
8. 29:59can't have a deep grasp of one without a deep grasp of the other they are…
9. 34:04hold of dying Greenfields book the Sabbath Thank You field netbook goes through the 39 block…
10. 38:12to a holiday experience isn't it sort of like doing religion but then isn't you're using…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.