Beki'in Bahalacha 6 - Shiur 43: Siman 159: 10

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Eli Mansour’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

by his the children Solomon and Mal and the grandchildren Ezra and Ed. So we have today a very very uh comprehensive discussion on different type of vessels that would be kosher for yadim or not. So in discusses a sprinkling can. What is the sprinkling can? So basically it has on the bottom perforated holes so the water comes out I guess a sprinkle a garden or something like that and also has a hole on top it's like a it's a shape of a bell and um the writes that as long as somebody keeps his finger pressed tightly on the opening on the top so that's science so no water is going to come out from the bottom so the container he says may be used for so the container was made to be used in such a way as a sprinkling can is considered a viable ki. So the he demonstrated some post disagreed with this ruling but in practice we could rely on the opinion of man. Okay. If the holes on the bottom are large enough so basically you're able to contain the water in there through science. You only put your finger on the top the water will not come out of the bottom. The k was made originally for that. So that's not considered a broken vessel or a you know a kily that has uh is damaged.

Jump to a moment

1. 0:32by his the children Solomon and Mal and the grandchildren Ezra and Ed. So we have…
2. 2:38is going to spill out. So, the question then really is becomes does the vessel for…
3. 5:17shapeless. And therefore other containers they might not be able to stand on their own. They…
4. 7:58no good why because it can't stand on its own you lies flat no good so…
5. 10:34soup ladle like the sprinkling can or is the soup ladle like the leather pouch? So…
6. 13:16in the airport. You're not going to believe it. And we saw a guy um uh…
7. 16:01really not made to hold beverages once it's empty, you throw it out. No, no, you…
8. 18:45Feinstein okay in a pinch he said it was okay but didn't like a kidoo was…
9. 21:24So it stands straight and lined the inside with pitch so it's waterproof. He nevertheless may…
10. 24:04is today if it's a vessel and it could hold it if you eat even though…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.