Jewish Autonomy, Conditional Gittin | Rabbi Yitzchak Breitowitz | February 17th 2026

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Yitzchak Breitowitz’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

dedicated anonymously for the f lay of a batgalina anonymously eli nishma nama from marisha until today and in loving memory of Laura Spiegler Ahuva Bashimarahu by her family again. May everything be leil nisham. Uh we uh were looking last week at a letter uh that the Rambam wrote to a Dion in in Alexandria Rapinas Hakoen. Uh and we see that they had a little bit Uh and we see that they had a little bit of a tense uh relationship and I'm not going to spend much more time in this letter other than to point out that yet another facet here that Rav Pinas uh basically accused the Rambam. Why did you say publicly that I'm an Ore who is ignorant of Hala? And the Rambam more or less said, well, I didn't quite say that, although I almost said that. And the Rambam offered a very interesting observation. The Rambam said there was a difference Rambam said there was a difference between Jews who came from Mus Muslim countries as the Rambam versus Jews who came from Christian countries such as Rapinako who came from France. And he says the difference was the ability of the Jewish community to exercise judicial autonomy. And that is the Muslims basically recognized the Jewish people as a separate legal community and allowed them to have their own courts. Granted, there was a lot of persecution for sure,

Jump to a moment

1. 0:35dedicated anonymously for the f lay of a batgalina anonymously eli nishma nama from marisha until…
2. 6:13for example, marriage uh uh if I get that job that uh I hope to get…
3. 11:50times can [snorts] be a well besides the inherent tragedy of missing an action it also…
4. 17:38land. We'll leave our women and children and our flocks here and we will participate in…
5. 23:25the positive and the negative. Again, I'm not giving you logic here. I'm just giving you…
6. 29:41already happened meaning if a man gives a get on the condition that something already happened…
7. 35:26have to have a base and determine what the equivalents are. But but in lotes, if…
8. 41:11his own but again you know maybe uh I don't know if he would be insulted.…
9. 47:00the best vehicle to convey philosophical abstract ideas. It is said that Hebrew is a or…
10. 52:36In Hebrew, the verb may precede the subject. Now, Iben Tibbon was lit literal in following…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.