Maseches Nedarim Daf 5, Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

and we're starting three lines from the top I will be out of town tomorrow um it is every likelihood that I will be uh recording and posting the odds of me being in front of a computer at that time or is very low so um hopefully over the course of the early parts of the day or I should say even better whenever I get to upload a share I will I don't know when that's only going to be on the website oh I could I could upload it to podbean to to the podcasts also but it probably won't be on YouTube yeah but I could do that I I normally don't do that because I'm lazy but oh well all right let's get started um yesterday at the conclusion of the gemara we were learning about the sheets of shmuel and if you look at the last three lines of dollar to Mid base we learned about schmuel that uh basically shmuel is of the opinion that if you say this phrase and now we're on the top of ham and that's the only phrase you said then both people would be also to one another we debated what is or the other person might incur if they don't follow the rules but uh be that as it made the gemara then said that he said the same thing and the gumar is now going to question that shita of Rubio how could you say that both of them are going to be awesome after all the gemara says that if I place upon you okay this the gemara assumes is similar to mujrani which is a very broad type of language instead of a narrow type of language there we don't see masuring what do we see they are hamud in a case of then the

Jump to a moment

1. 0:06and we're starting three lines from the top I will be out of town tomorrow um…
2. 2:08me there is no is Sir so that's a specific case where okay you're adding more…
3. 4:51that says that the hamak language and we said on the bottom of the previous page…
4. 7:23this really is shmuel's from the bottom of dalidoma Base what really did he says really…
5. 10:05shmuel is saying that when you do a double phrase like this then it's enough that's…
6. 12:38the challenge of a yacht is that we need to try and find the Line in…
7. 14:49we can say that really in the mishnah is like the rabbona that is that it's…
8. 17:30right well we're going to discuss a little bit of that yeah so well there's a…
9. 20:10there's not not because of the statistics but because there's there's nothing to hold on to…
10. 22:56of guys look at the get this get I'm not divorcing somebody else there's names and…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.