Rabbi Raymond Haber - Shabbat Daf Mem Zayin 47

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Raymond Haber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

why you not let it put on according to the bishon why you not allowed to carry a n if you're afraid that it's going to go out the says the reason why because it's you're not shall have it is it's you're not shall have it is considered because maybe maybe because it's maybe because it's if you pull it out it's going to go it's going to go out and therefore the whole the whole the whole n is there to support this shall have it the flame right the flame the flame is not a physical object it's it still has a if you pull it out it's going to go out that makes it out it's going to go out that makes it is the that's what it's there for right the whole thing is there to support this flame that that's all how does it make something else the whole thing is a basis to that that's what it's it itself even not because he's afraid that it's GNA go out but because shall it GNA go out but because shall it is not clear maybe he holds Like a Rock right by the it says right so it becomes it's a support it's a for that so therefore everything when you have a basis the basis becomes to the item that it's supporting let's see not not a common gave me the to carry a is a fire pen they used to put coals in it to keep them warm or or this one was a Rashi says this one was they would put incense in it in order to make the house smell good let's

Jump to a moment

1. 0:12why you not let it put on according to the bishon why you not allowed to…
2. 5:38now okay so what what is he saying he says because has because just have that's…
3. 11:00disgusting so to over here you're allowed to take out the uh you're allowed to take…
4. 16:17an equal like the the next question let's see says so we'll ask a question to…
5. 21:48finishing you're finishing a Kelly you're putting the final whoever finishes something is for finish you…
6. 27:22constantly and maybe he sets up for a week I don't know how long he sets…
7. 33:26fire says the G how you allowed to put a Kelly to catch when the they…
8. 38:47water puts out fire that's that's what we learn right so when you put the water…
9. 44:01if you put it on it would be so because people don't see it like that…
10. 49:57but as it's sittings up you know I saw this morning on Wikipedia that the word…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.