Rabbi Raymond Haber - Shabbat Daf Het (8)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Raymond Haber’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

says if he stuck a pole in and he threw something and landed on top of the pole even if the pole is 100 goes up to the the goes up to the sky now what about landing on a place that's full by four didn't we say you have to land on a place that's 4 by4 holds like what Rashi says what does it [Music] say where that if you threw something and landed on a Ledge that's a that's what's it called that's a small and forgetting the sug that we already learned this already it sounds like within four with if it even though it doesn't have holds it and hold it so says we're thinking he's thr from says no if he was thrown in the in if it was Landing in proper don't assume that is only according to the and he argues on the really dies is like everybody even the will agree that in you don't need why is full it's better it's good we're talking about a tree standing in and a branch is sticking out to and he threw it and it landed on the branch says so now Rashi says we're changing the case sort of not like we said before he threw from the to the no he threw four which is a different but I don't need a landing in I need a landing in the and even if you're going to tell me that in you even without landing on a 4x4 for some reason doesn't have that requirement but still has that requirement now even so so even though it's Landing in theim holds you're going to be says we we we we put the the branches we give it the same qualities as the as the base and when you're throwing it's considered Landing in the in in

Jump to a moment

1. 0:04says if he stuck a pole in and he threw something and landed on top of…
2. 5:34nobody needs a friend and like that the second everybody would agree in when did they…
3. 10:58yeah oh you P if you move the wagon right so now if I have this…
4. 16:26that means you have four time two fifths means you get you get uh you get…
5. 21:59we got a lot more to do and this it's very rough r rough day today…
6. 27:47by the time the the Leading Edge gets under under three the top Edge is still…
7. 33:12knees that's not part of the yesterday we wanted to let the guy between the poles…
8. 38:31over there that's enough we're we're we're stretching we're stretching it a little bit no you…
9. 43:46because the bo is a carit I'm in the I'm not allow to carry from car…
10. 49:10fact that I'm gonna walk through even though it's nobody wants to walk through this huge…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.