Maseches Chullin Daf 82b and 83a, Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Okay, good evening. Hope you're all doing well. Today we're learning pad. Oh, even yeah. We're going to start at the Mishna on the bottom of and we're going to go to the Mishna toward the bottom of Gimal. It's quite a large number of words. So, we'll do as well as we can. Says the Mishna as follows. If one she a cow and then one separately two of its children right so that's a double violation and the garra says that is going to be 80 lashes if one the animal and its daughter so it's three generations the garra says so the first animal was mut and the second two animals respectively were each uh were each going to be were each going to be if the animal was the so you skip a generation the mother was then the granddaughter was the and afterwards the middle generation was this case is more nuanced so it's generation one generation three generation two. So the Gomorrah says there is malos of one is very interesting because he generation one generation three generation two we're going to have to get into this because once he the middle generation so that middle generation is really both it's really three generations in a row views it like the previous case of doing it in order and the tanakama views it as doing it not in Okay. Says the Gomorra, why is it that one would be in why would is it that one would be if it's done out of order? If

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01Okay, good evening. Hope you're all doing well. Today we're learning pad. Oh, even yeah. We're…
2. 3:46says the wait one second. The Pik says lo you wanted to say that that means…
3. 8:02we say that is of the opinion that and of course the same is true in…
4. 12:24today and pay bas who holds that if you the mother the grandmother and then you…
5. 16:41What a what a unique. How could you only be you? So says the gammor. What…
6. 21:04So what do we see over here? We see the same exact idea that it's very…
7. 24:45Don't leave the food over. But if you leave the food over, that in the morning…
8. 29:21which is 40. If you say it by for sure you're going to say it here.…
9. 33:42at the end of all the a different of poorly understood area of which is why…
10. 38:15and therefore then the losses go to the mo if the animal dies. So then is…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.