Shabbos 12a

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Peretz Segal’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

okay so we're going on to B but we're beginning at the bottom of Al B and what we're trying to reconcile is there was a previous between that the wanted to posit as being the reason why um a Tradesman carrying a part of his tools of trade would be considered either a pro or not would be considered either a pro or not on shabas and the wanted to say that understood that um it's an abnormal thing to do and therefore it's unreasonable and therefore it's only a Prohibition rically whereas would say that if it's the way that he would normally carry it so then even though it's an abnormal way for the average person car it that's still considered an Isa and that's how the gar wanted to reconcile the Brer in order not to pose reconcile the Brer in order not to pose a difficulty on Rober who say that we don't make a double prohibition a double Gaz or a double decree so that's just a bit of background but the gor introduces us to a contradiction between seeming contradiction between two mishna which are tangentially or conceptually conceptually related even though they um don't have a direct bearing on Tradesmen and it's talking about as we mentioned previous as of a person that's having emissions one BR says that he can use a

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00okay so we're going on to B but we're beginning at the bottom of Al B…
2. 2:35abnormality for the normal person that it can be considered no problem according to law and…
3. 5:11say from dirt he expresses his opinion in regard to the idea of food be contracting…
4. 7:50like I don't want the water to hit the wall and as a result the water…
5. 10:23the in these two bres has got nothing to do what we've discussed before there's an…
6. 13:03the the name of actually wrote had written on holy to and it had the name…
7. 15:39light of the By the Light of the candle and not not by the light of…
8. 18:13we're about to expand upon a bit further but before we get you can't even use…
9. 20:48throw them away but you can't kill them and this is talking about on is even…
10. 23:26to have a um teacher of tah on neither a teacher of a trade you can't…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.