Rabbi Yosef Shmueli

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Musayof Synagogue’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

Ben Sharshana >> Faruch Levi ben Miriam Marjoum, for a full recovery Tziporah bat Marcel Efrat , Tziporah bat Marcel Khatun, may God grant her a full recovery The Mishna says: "A 'yotzei dofen'(c-section birth ) and the one that comes after it, Rabbi Tarfon says both shall graze until they become blemished" And they shall be eaten by the owners. Rabbi Akiva says, neither of them is a firstborn. The first, because it is not a "peter rechem"(womb-opener) And the second, because another preceded it. Good. So a firstborn born from an animal in the normal way, it was a " peter rechem." It opened. It opened the womb and came out first, so it is simple that it has the status of a firstborn. But now we have a "yotzei dofen" here. "Yotzei dofen" is as we know today, what is called a Caesarean section, where the animal could not give birth, so they operated on her and took out the calf or the lamb from the side. From the belly itself, so it is called a "yotzei dofen"—it came out from the side, not the opening. And therefore let us see, Rabbi Tarfon is actually in doubt whether it has the status of a firstborn or not. And he is not only in doubt about that: if this "

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00Ben Sharshana >> Faruch Levi ben Miriam Marjoum, for a full recovery Tziporah bat Marcel Efrat…
2. 3:13second is not a firstborn because another preceded it. Even though it is indeed a "peter…
3. 7:01rule that says we often have a general rule in the Torah that needs a detail,…
4. 10:47not say the text says "firstborn." Yes? As we said, from the word "firstborn," you cannot…
5. 14:30is a firstborn," then witness this! A male was born via cesarean, and then a male…
6. 18:12cattle it is a discharge, And with large ones it is a placenta. So he says…
7. 21:51>> Yes, in the majority of their cases, they conceive and give birth within a year.…
8. 25:33minors are not eunuchs. And also regarding minor girls, follow the majority of minor girls, and…
9. 30:22ox and my donkey that caused damage are liable, but my slave and my maidservant that…
10. 34:08recite...why? >> No, he derives pleasure from it... >> Yes, he also enjoys it. >> You…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.