Amud Yomi Masechet Shabbat Daf 4A

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Dovid Hofstedter’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

[Music] D Amed Olive will begin giml Amed B 12 lines from the bottom so we were in the middle of a discussion we had seemingly a steer in the bryces one Bry says that if a person he extends his hands filled with Pairs and he extends it into another sh one Bry says that it's aler to retrieve it it's aler to bring it back and the other Bry says that it's motored to bring it back now as we discussed previously this is not like the case of the mishna the case of the mishna where we said that an Akira without a or without Akira is also this is not the same as the case of the mishna because in the case of the mishna there was a complete there was there was an Akira and transferring from one to the other the issue over there was is that there was not one person who did both the and even there's no because to be one person has to do the complete Mal but there was an and there was a done between the two of them now here if the person extends his hands filled with Paris from one R to the other and he retrieves It ultimately there is no HW there is no huw no transferring one one from one R to the other R so the question over here is did the RAB also make aera that they consant the person and say you cannot bring it back and you cannot retrieve it so that was the Shila and we seem to have a steerer in the two bryces one Bryce says you can and one says you can't so the last terance that the gorah gave was how do we resolve this we resolve this by saying that it makes a difference it depends if when he

Jump to a moment

1. 0:02[Music] D Amed Olive will begin giml Amed B 12 lines from the bottom so we…
2. 2:43he didn't but that was not severe enough to give AAS and say you can't retrieve…
3. 5:55dough in the oven now he's not yet did they allow him to remove it did…
4. 9:14there's an alternate way of learning the Bryson you do not have to learn as we…
5. 12:29you can't learn out that be on Ras now let's look at the other side so…
6. 15:46say you can retrieve it why it says you can it depends is he retrieving it…
7. 18:27won't be able to you won't be able to compare the two together if you if…
8. 21:35baked but he knows now that that it's would he be in any event a person…
9. 24:56stays over there it'll be B and he'll be other people are seeing it can they…
10. 28:08of somebody you could do it so that it'll ultimately end up being a miss and…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.