Shaar HaBitachon Lesson 15 with Rabbi Shais Taub

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shais Taub’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

so I wanted to I got a I got a an email I haven't done questions and answers in a while but I got an email last night after the shear and I wanted to respond to it it's actually somebody who is usually on live so I feel you know they get priority if you're part of the live group so we fast track your your questions so it was so would you say I'm reading now the email so would you say that theoretically Hashem will give good no matter what but practically we mess it up for ourselves when we don't act on the Torah mitzvahs which are for our benefit and that puts us at odds with our supposing to talking thanks for this series greatly appreciated wanted to learn shadow but talking for the longest time and this gave me the impetus yeah so I'll ask I'll answer the I'll address the first thing second and the second thing first so thank you for coming to the class and giving me an impetus to go through shot of a talking again definitely this learning in this format and in this forum is a whole new level for me and has really added to my appreciation of the of the safer so regarding this question I'm not sure exactly that I would formulate it that way because you say theoretically I shall give no matter what but practically we mess it up for ourselves i I don't want to agree with that formulation because that it implies that there's no situation where we're hash em won't give mercifully if if we don't do what he says and the truth is that he does he

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00so I wanted to I got a I got a an email I haven't done questions…
2. 2:23does give mercifully so if you if you if you phrase it us theoretically and practically…
3. 5:10don't have betoken because I'm not submitting to his will for me because if I had…
4. 7:53that be talking stronger so yeah it is certainly not an all-or-nothing proposition we'd be in…
5. 10:46arguing and we never we can never reach a conclusion so how do we understand this…
6. 13:35think about your Souls relationship with a sham it's sort of like hovering around you but…
7. 15:40that he's going to be able to make a living and emotionally he doesn't feel that…
8. 18:20other words it's not like he's either someone who doesn't have integrated faith or he is…
9. 20:58to read that last part but if I understand what you're writing yes I that's if…
10. 23:45relationship with people wasn't like the kind of relationship that we have with people where we…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.