Can One Hear the Megila Through the Phone or on Zoom?

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shay Tahan’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

hello this year many people ask about creative aguila since the pandemic still goes on and people want to know can they beyonce through an instrument like the zoom app or any other app or other means but the answer to that is that we can't be obsessed only by person you have to hear the megillah or read the megillah from a megi lakshera in person that goes for men and women alike because women are also obligated in hearing the megillah at night and in the day and you can't be obsessed through any of those electronical instruments and there's a few reasons for that first of all the hearing itself according to manipur scheme is not considered hearing it from the person that is reading from the megillah rather you have to hear straight from him when he's present and he can't use any of those means even wrote about such a thing when he was uh speaking about using a microphone he said microphone can't be used if you can't hear the megillah without the microphone and therefore over here also let's say on the phone since you can't hear the person reading without having the phone therefore

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00hello this year many people ask about creative aguila since the pandemic still goes on and…
2. 0:30in person that goes for men and women alike because women are also obligated in hearing…
3. 1:00straight from him when he's present and he can't use any of those means even wrote…
4. 1:31hearing it through the phone is not sufficient other schemes say that there's no reason at…
5. 2:02that disagree even to make me a neem in such a way that you have a…
6. 2:32bohot that's affect a man like hell amen has to be dealt as the baha'i itself…
7. 3:02you and him there is a church of a dozer or something else that interrupts the…
8. 3:32house and read it with a distance or he should read it himself to buy yourself…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.