Biur Chametz | Shiur by Rav Asher Weiss Shlit"a (5779)

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Asher Weiss’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

to save from Minchas to the Quiver. You have one here? No, no, no. I don't need one. I'm just curious. So, on tough memory hey >> [clears throat] >> the very first safe in Shulchan Aruch Ketzad Biur Chametz. Sorfey o porer l'ruach o zerah k'leyam. o zerah k'leyam. And this is a like a stenum whether ein biur chametz elah s'reifuh or hashboso b'chol davar. That is perek beis in Maseches Pesachim. The Minchas Chinuch in Mitzvah Tes has a very well-known chokirah. And his question is how do we define the mitzvah of Tashbisu se'or mibeteichem, [snorts] the mitzvah of um service chametz. Is it a mitzvah d'oraysa or a mitzvah d'shelo d'oraysa? or a mitzvah d'shelo d'oraysa? Is the mitzvah to destroy chametz either by burning or in any other way? Or the mitzvah is not to have chametz. And the Minchas Chinuch gives two nafka minas between the two different interpretations of Tashbisu. If the mitzvah is to destroy chametz, If the mitzvah is to destroy chametz, a person doesn't have any chametz after Pesach, he would have a mitzvah to buy chametz to be mekuyem the mitzvah of Tashbisu. So, even the Minchas Chinuch would agree, if he didn't have any chametz before Pesach and neither did he buy chametz, he's not a mevatel mitzvah say, mitzvah say, but he's losing out. He doesn't he's not mekuyem the mitzvah. However, if the mitzvah is the result and not to have chametz, then he actually is mekuyem the mitzvah of Tashbisu se'or mibeteichem by the mere

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00to save from Minchas to the Quiver. You have one here? No, no, no. I don't…
2. 4:37the the mitzvah is not the etzem bitul, neither the etzem s'reifuh, but rather the result.…
3. 9:45it is a mitzvah d'aseh d'oraysa. So, why wouldn't we say ein l'chod davar she'na'aseh mitzvoso…
4. 14:48So in daf hey, Rashi says according to the man d'amar b'chol davar, you could feed…
5. 19:23it means you need to have some level of to know which of the mitzvahs a…
6. 24:28without any social benefits I would show him up what are you happy about he says…
7. 29:39to be to assume that you need to do the misses all of them and all…
8. 34:14you don't do the kind of seed is it is not that long. It's not the…
9. 39:20biggest we spoke about this at length. But I but I think in reality the meaning…
10. 44:29Yes. That's a very good question. But we're not dealing with near service. I think it's…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.