Lehallel
Getting it ready…

Torah · 8:51

Is One Obligated to Heal a Friends Animal? The Machlokes Ran & Rosh {DH Iyun Sugya Nedarim 41b}

124 views · Aug 11, 2025

Rabbi Daniel Glatstein

Ask this shiur

Ask in your own words — the answer is the exact moment this shiur speaks to it.

What’s said in this shiur

Jump to a moment

  1. 0:00progress. >> Okay. The garra says that referring to what it said in the Mishna, not…
  2. 0:32be. So the mission should say that outright says the garra noes is healing the person…
  3. 1:34it has to be talking about where there's another doctor. Otherwise, if there wasn't another doctor,…
  4. 2:04somebody else still. I'm allowed to heal you because a person is not to be healed…
  5. 3:07is found on the bottom left hand side of the page. The last narrow lines, the…
  6. 4:09Likewise says look in the bottom right hand side says it's not like returning an object.…
  7. 4:42So the want to know why is this different? If I'm obligated to return your animal…
  8. 5:46sim says something a little bit differently. Mayor Simka says that we're talking about a wound…
  9. 6:19Indian of healing you have to heal someone if it's just a matter of his loss…
  10. 7:20fundamentally it could be or because it since it's a illness that will heal so and…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.

More from Rabbi Daniel Glatstein

Get the week’s best, by email

One email a week — a handful of shiurim and music. No account needed.

Know a family who would use this? Give a Lehallel membership.