Maseches Bava Kama 53, Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Daf Yomi with Rabbi Phil Karesh’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

all right good evening today we're learning and we're starting what no and I'm on the very bottom line of nun um we had discussed a scenario in our previous Mna the previous Mna that we had learned is in the middle of N and we discussed a den that if an animal heard the sound of the shovel digging and then it fell into a hole so if the animal fell forward so then potentially the mishna says you'd be if the animal the mishna says you'd be if the animal fell backwards so then you'd be poter that's what the mishna said let's analyze of the fun of mish it means literally falling forward and the Mish means you're literally falling backwards um that if you fall forwards you're going to be we'll soon see that this is how R explains things because that then leads to the he issue where you're kind of nose diving into the heav and that's going to lead to death um and um means you're you're dying not because of the he because you went backwards and of the he because you went backwards and therefore you die because of you die because the animal hits its body on the ground and therefore RAV would say because R hold the the car that doesn't belong to you what belongs to you is what you cut out you carved out that there should be the he so therefore you're going to be poter when you die when the animal dies by this is exactly like we saw earlier just a few blo on top of Top Line

Jump to a moment

1. 0:01all right good evening today we're learning and we're starting what no and I'm on the…
2. 3:10but to fall in says you're going to be no matter what whether or not it…
3. 6:45there in such a case when the damage of the shore falling in was such a…
4. 9:52holds that you're allowed to collect from any of the players involved anyone who has cash…
5. 13:27says that according to the tanama the Balor is completely putter Reb is saying no way…
6. 17:04balore and 1/4th was being paid by the balash but the way the gor wanted to…
7. 20:06this was a case we saw earlier that we didn't like because if you say that…
8. 23:53according to the tanama would say only one person is accountable re would say collect money…
9. 27:01than the's owed and that would be that would be a couple of different ways to…
10. 30:35from the bottom of or two thirds down from the top actually was so clear that…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library where each video was reviewed against one written standard before it could appear. No ads, no comments, no autoplay into anything unapproved.