Rabbi's view on NON-JEWISH birthrate in the Holy Land may SHOCK you | ETHICAL DILEMMAS Part 2

What’s said in this shiur

The opening of this shiur, in Rabbi Shais Taub’s own words — taken from the captions, so names and Hebrew terms may be approximate.

we're looking at ethical dilemmas from a deeper spiritual view a metaphysical view uh getting into some of the otherw worldly Concepts that are behind the legal discussions of ethical dilemas in Torah and in Jewish tradition okay so I'll start off last week I think we covered like three dilemmas more or less um I'm not sure how many will cover tonight but I'll start off with a nice controversial one and uh I'll present it in terms of a story because really it's a discussion it's a conversation between two rabbis one of those rabbis is lab and this discussion took place in the laich's office at 770 Eastern Parkway Crown Heights when he was visited on the Hebrew datein me that is June 18th 1980 by Rabbi aam Yakov fredman otherwise known as the sadur RAB sadur RAB is if you're into mology you know the uh the dynasty of ran RAB raner who was one of the great uh RAB is of the 19th century and he was a direct descendant of the mid many different dynasties come from him so the sador is descended from the raner and he had actually just assumed leadership of his cidus the previous year in 1979 and their Community originally ran is in Ukraine and they uh were in Central Europe for a while in in Austria but uh the this sadab that we're speaking about in this story was based inel in uh B so a lot of the discussion that he had with the rebba was about the situation in the land of Israel so there's a recording of this conversation by the way there's an audio recording of the entire conversation um in Yiddish but at one point in the conversation the sad laments that the Israeli

Jump to a moment

1. 0:00we're looking at ethical dilemmas from a deeper spiritual view a metaphysical view uh getting into…
2. 5:13United States government to some extent you know they have child tax credits um and populations…
3. 10:22Mitzvah like Commandments are the children of of Noah now all human beings are ended from…
4. 15:32in the land of Israel and non-jewish families also have big families we're actually doing a…
5. 20:40conversation to say but land for peace is not even a discussion but then in the…
6. 25:51pro-choice so let me let me just give like a five minute background in the most…
7. 31:05law that in a very specific case vigilante justice or extrajudicial Justice is permitted and not…
8. 36:14their town to gamble and the chief of police was cracking down on gambling and he…
9. 41:27philosophical discussions ethical dilemmas in philosophy every college kid who took ethics 101 if that's a…
10. 46:40popular and beloved so that when he passed away the entire nation was crying by the…

Every second of this shiur plays inside Lehallel — a filtered YouTube library of Torah, music and shiurim. No ads, no comments, no autoplay.